Financial Columnist Almost Gets It

by Sean

Why, oh why, do I torture myself and bother reading anything by Robert Kiyosaki? I should really know better.

His latest article at Yahoo almost gets it right, except when he gets it wrong.

He argues, quite rightly, that high management fees on many mutual funds cut into earnings in a truly massive way. In the example he gives (which is just a direct quote from John Bogle‘s recent interview on a Frontline episode), 80% of the potential gains are lost by a little 2.5% management fee over a 65 year investment timeline.

But then he goes on to say :

“Occasionally, I will buy a mutual fund. But I’ll never hold it for a long period of time.”

If he believes that they are such poor investments, then why hold them at all, even for a short time? Almost gets it? Scratch that. Kiyosaki is a moron.

He continues his claims that active investors can regularly beat passive investing results (whatever regularly means), which I’d argue isn’t true. But at the very least, Kiyosaki does offer up a little good advice and recommends low fee index funds. Too bad that’s just for us passive investors.

  • http://www.thinkingaboutmoney.com kibitzer

    Robert Kiyosaki doesn’t offer investment advice (and when he does, it should largely be ignored). What he does do (brilliantly) is offer philosophy – a way to look at our financial lives. I’ve written an e-Book you might enjoy that discusses his work and where it is (and isn’t) valuable. See http://www.thinkingaboutmoney.com/?page_id=5

  • http://www.irregularpayments.com Sean

    Well, for someone who doesn’t offer investment advice, quite a few of the columns he’s written for Yahoo are just jam packed with it.

    Anyone who arbitrarily changes common definitions within the realm that they’re speaking is just being intellectually dishonest. You may feel he’s in a different domain than investment, but Kiyosaki himself is, apparently, perfectly comfortable claiming to speak in that field. For instance, his “house is liability” tripe, which you’ve written off as domain specific language, really bothers me when he is peddling his advice as financial in nature.

Previous post:

Next post: